New York Strip Steak: Best Cooking Methods


Who doesn’t like a good steak? Often loved by entire families, a steak dinner is certainly something for everyone to look forward to. Steaks are simple enough to be prepared by pretty much anyone, ranging from professional chefs to first-time kitchen adventurers. It’s funny how some of the best dishes can often be made in the simplest of ways, with the use of very few ingredients. One such dish is a New York strip steak.

If you’ve never made one before, rest assured that it’s very quick and easy — provided you learn a few basic steps.

Restaurant-grade steaks are not reserved solely for your nights out. You don’t need to pay extra for something that you can prepare with a serving of good meat and a few ingredients found in most homes. It also helps to have a good cast iron skillet, but not having one won’t mean that you have to head to a bar or a restaurant. There are ways around that, too.

Is it dinner time yet? Then let us give you some ideas on how to prepare a New York strip steak the right way. There are several options for you to choose from, each tried and tested by professional chefs. All that’s left to do is to get reading, work up an appetite, and start cooking your delicious steak!

What do you need to prepare a strip steak?

Before we get to discuss all the different methods, you need to make sure that you’ve got all the ingredients ready at home. A steak is as delicious as it is easy to prepare, so there’s not a whole lot that you’ll need to get before you start cooking.

The type of meat that you pick plays the biggest part in the success of your meal. Different types of beef are suited to different dishes, and not every cut is going to suit a steak. As the main method of preparing a steak is called pan-searing, you will want a cut that is suited precisely to that.

What type of meat do you need for a steak?

Pan-searing favors boneless cuts that cook rather quickly. The NY strip slice should be no more than one and a half-inch thick, and preferably with a generous amount of fat. There are some recipes that call for slow-cooking cuts, such as beef stew or roast beef. However, to cook a good steak, go with our recommendation.

What else do you need for a NY steak?

Cook your steak with the following ingredients

  • 2 NY strip steaks (1-1.5″ thick, about 12 oz each)
  • salt and pepper (you can also use kosher salt; black pepper is recommended; you will need more than 1 teaspoon of each)
  • oil
  • butter
  • fresh thyme (optional) or other herbs

You can also add your own seasonings, such as store-bought steak seasoning, garlic, or marjoram. However, make sure not to overdo it — you don’t want the seasoning to cover up the natural taste of the steak.

Now that you’ve got all your ingredients, it’s time to get cookin’!

How do you cook a New York strip steak on top of the stove?

Preparing steak in a pan on top of the stove is the most popular and fail-proof method out there. For this method, you should preferably have a cast-iron pan, but another type will also do.

When it comes to preparing strip steaks, many people use the pan-searing technique briefly mentioned above. It’s fail-proof and makes delicious, well-made, crispy steaks. There are some variants to the method that we will describe in our steps below.

Let the steaks sit for 30 minutes

Before you begin cooking, take your steaks out of the fridge and let them thaw for around 30-40 minutes. Once that time passes, pat the steaks dry with clean paper towels. This will help speed up the cooking process, as it removes moisture, which has to evaporate before the meat starts browning.

Season your steaks

Add generous helpings of salt and pepper (or kosher salt and pepper) on both sides of the steaks, making sure to season evenly with a rather thick layer. This will then stick to the surface of the steak and turn into a mouth-watering crust.

If you’re using any additional type of seasoning, now is the time to also apply it. Check first to make sure that it doesn’t have an additional helping of salt and/or pepper. You don’t want to overdo it.

Prepare the pan

Turn on your exhaust fan if you have one — it really helps! Next, grab a cast-iron pan or a stainless steel pan. These pans are the best for cooking steaks because they can withstand high heat. The pan should be rather spacious: you don’t want the steaks to be too close together.

Heat up your pan over medium-high heat for a few minutes. It has to be really hot before you place your steaks in the pan. After a while, add oil to the pan. You want to cover the entire pan with a thin layer of oil.

Once the oil begins to shimmer after 2-3 minutes, set your steaks down into the pan. Be VERY careful when you do this and make sure you do it facing away from you because oil splatters can be highly dangerous.

Cook your steaks

For the next few moments (anywhere between 3 and 5 minutes), just leave the steaks to cook. Do not flip them over; simply allow them to reach the desired temperature in the sizzling oil. This will help them develop a brown, crispy crust.

You can flip the steaks over once they release easily without sticking to the bottom of the pan. The underside of the steaks should have a deep brown color at this point.

Once you’ve flipped them over, keep cooking them for another 3 to 4 minutes on the bottom side. This should help you make a rare or medium-rare steak.  This whole process should only take about 10 minutes.

Finish up with butter

If you’ve only got about a minute left on your cooking timer, add a tablespoon of butter to the pan. You can also add some fresh thyme, marjoram, or another type of herb. This isn’t a required step, but it adds a lot of flavor to the steaks.

Serve the steaks

The cooking process should now be over! If you’re going to be eating the steaks uncut, all you need to do is transfer them to a plate. If you’re cutting them into slices, move them to a cutting board and leave them to rest for 10 minutes. Make sure you cover them with aluminum foil. Once that time has passed, you can slice them thinly by going against the grain.

That’s all! In a total time of less than twenty minutes (plus the initial waiting period at the start), you’ve prepared a delicious dinner for two. All from the comfort of your own home!

If you still have some remaining questions, consult our FAQ below to obtain all the knowledge you might need about preparing steaks.

How do you cook a New York strip steak in a cast iron skillet?

Choosing a cast-iron skillet for preparing your steak is definitely the way to go. You need lots and lots of heat to cook a good steak. As cast-iron preserves heat very well, these pans are favorites amongst many, including chefs that work in some of the best steakhouses in the world.

As a cast-iron skillet generates a good amount of heat on its own, you can forego the use of oil when preparing your steaks on this type of pan. This gives you a lower-calorie, healthier option if you’re looking to lose a few pounds or simply just eat well.

When it comes to cast-iron skillets, you need a specific type that will be perfect for steaks. If you plan to cook two at a time, this pan should also be relatively large, as you need plenty of room between the two steaks.

To make things a little easier, we’d like to recommend a set of skillets that impressed us a lot and helped us prepare the perfect steak.

Legend Cast Iron Set

Legend Cookware Cast Iron Skillet Set of 3 CHEF’S TRIO | Pan Set of...
628 Reviews
Legend Cookware Cast Iron Skillet Set of 3 CHEF’S TRIO | Pan Set of...
  • THE PAN. THE MYTH. THE LEGEND – Famous for lifelong durability and workhorse versatility, Legend Cookware combines a rich heritage with the modern cook’s needs. Cast from solid, pure,...
  • A MODERN TAKE ON A CLASSIC – Contemporary features include a smoother finish, long integrated handles on each skillet, and a bonus pan scraper for delicious fond and cleaning. Works with all...

For steaks bigger and smaller, why not make sure you’re fully equipped right from the get-go? By getting this set of three excellent skillets, you’re setting yourself up for success. Whether you’re going to cook a single steak or a large family dinner, these cast-iron frying pans will help you.

Made out of solid, pure, high-quality steel and iron, these non-stick skillets are heavy, but also very durable. Reported to be capable of lasting a whole lifetime, you can consider them a solid investment that will last for years. Making as much as a dent in one of these pans is next to impossible!

They offer great heat distribution, making sure that your steak cooks and browns evenly throughout the entire pan. They have a smooth finish that makes it easy to flip the steak without risk.

Each skillet comes with an integrated handle. These handles are of appropriate length, so you don’t have to worry about drops of oil sizzling out from the skillet and onto your hands.  They can be used with all cooktops, including the stovetop, an oven, and even a live campfire.

If you want to make sure that you have the best set of cast-iron pans for all your steak needs, check out Legend Cast Iron.

Check price on Amazon


How do you make a NY steak tender?

The pan-searing method described above is ideal for cooking a very tender steak. You’re going to be able to enjoy a nice crust thanks to cooking the steak in high heat, but the inside will remain tender, flavorful, and moist.

There’s another reason why we have full faith in your steak turning out the right way. This is due to the fact that the New York strip steak is naturally tender. With the right technique and the right cut, you’ve got all your steps to success nicely lined up in front of you, ready to eat after just a few minutes of cooking.

If you want to take some extra steps to ensure that your steak comes out tender, here are a few tips:

  • Use a meat thermometer to prevent overcooking. You want to reach 145 degrees Fahrenheit for a medium-rare steak, 160 degrees for medium, and lastly, 170 degrees for well-done.
  • Remember to let the steak rest for, at the very least, 3 minutes before serving.
  • When shopping, remember that a NY steak should have a little fat on it. This helps it store both flavor and moisture.
  • Ingredients: 2 steaks. This is the recommended amount in our recipe. The trick to making both of them flavorful is to keep them apart during the cooking process.

How do you cook a steak on a stove without a cast-iron skillet?

So you’ve got a massive craving for a steak, but you don’t have an iron skillet? No problem! There is a solid alternative to the good old cast-iron when you want to cook a steak. It comes in the form of stainless steel.

Stainless steel pans allow you to sear, fry, saute, and more with ease. They don’t hold heat quite as well as iron does, but they’re really a very close second. Most of us have at least one of these at home, so if you’re in a pinch, you can compromise.

In case you’d like to get yourself a new one, check out our favorite model below.

Mealthy Stainless Steel 10-inch Frying Pan

For most of your cooking needs, we think you’ll find this pan more than adequate. It’s a 10-inch pan, so it’s quite big and will fit two steaks without any issues.

Mealthy offers a restaurant-grade construction that is sturdy enough to withstand hundreds of hours of sizzling, cooking, frying, and more. It’s 3-millimeter thick and features 5-layer composite construction. The handle is ergonomic and easy to manage. It’s also sure to stay cool even during very high temperatures.

The outer layers of stainless steel work to protect the pan against corrosion, ensuring longevity. The inner layers are made out of aluminum and provide a surprisingly even heating experience. Having a steak that’s brown on just one end should not be a problem with this pan.

This pan is entirely nonstick, so you don’t have to worry about your steaks getting stuck to the bottom and, as a result, burning up. The smooth surface also makes it very easy to clean.

It’s suited to all types of cooktops: gas, ceramic, induction, and electric. You can also put it in the dishwasher. This is the type of pan that stays in a family for years. This statement is only re-inforced by the fact that Mealthy comes with a lifetime warranty.

Check price on Amazon



A good steak with a side of potatoes and a fresh salad is a simple, but an oh-so-delicious meal. It’s not at all time-consuming, but if prepared the right way, it can taste of luxury unmatched by the best restaurants.

Whether it’s a special night or just another Wednesday afternoon, it’s good to treat yourself to a wonderful dinner sometimes. Follow our steps and your dream steak will be just twenty minutes away!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top